The occurrence that Dr. Stockmann is surprised shows that he should have g one to Peter with the caper first. If he were really only interested in the town's and the duty' public assistance that is what he would have done. Instead his true motives come surface when he talks about contacting Kiil with his news. Kiil, he says, will be "astonished" since, the doctor manages, "he thinks I am cracked--and there are lots of other people think so too" (1444). The doctor's strongest motive (and the reason for his secretive approach) is found in the words, "but now these good folks shall fulfill--they shall just arrest" (144).
As an employee and a citizen the doctor had an obligation to investigate the affirmable dangers of the Baths. But he also desired to prove that he had been right all along about the chore of the tanneries. so his secrecy meant that if the tests proved him wrong no one would know about it. Since they proved him right, of course he was happy to see to doing the right thing. But it was beingness personally right that came first.
This problem becomes clearer when the doctor continues to make it a question of himself opposed to everyone else. forthwith his being right about the facts transforms itself into a question of being morally right. If everyone else was wrong about the pipes then everyone else also, it seems t
Dr. Stockmann does not make any concession to the business problems his comrade and the others face. People with less scientific knowledge allude that maybe there are less extreme ways of dealing with the problem. But Dr. Stockmann is not interested in discussing alternatives or practical possibilities. Thus when he is offered the chance to be the one who makes these decisions--through Kiil's diabolical plan--he is no longer concerned with anyone's eudaimonia.
Page add up and quotes given here are for the edition/translation cited and will vary considerably from text to text.
Dr. Stockmann has forced the hand of the business. His brother and the other directors of the spa company have no filling but to repress the news. If Dr. Stockmann had acted responsibly and had the interests of the town and the business at heart he would have given them the chance to gestate responsibly. Once they lose this opportunity, because of his immediate threat to expose the problem, he has made it impossible for them to act correctly. If they close down the Baths and channelise all the pipes they will have to spend thousands--which they will no longer have once the business fails--and they will, most likely, never be able to get the chance again since the town's study will be ruined.
o Dr. Stockmann, is morally wrong in response to the problem. At the public meeting he is no longer concerned with the danger to people who may catch the spa, and he never shows any concern about the welfare of the town and the business once th
Order your essay at Orderessay and get a 100% original and high-quality custom paper within the required time frame.
No comments:
Post a Comment